Saturday, March 17, 2012

The Voter Fraud Lie

Andrew Cohen:
Jonathan Chait, in a smart recent New York magazine piece titled "2012 or Never," offered some numbers supporting the theory. "Every year," Chait wrote, "the nonwhite proportion of the electorate grows by about half a percentage point -- meaning that in every presidential election, the minority share of the vote increases by 2 percent, a huge amount in a closely divided country." This explains, for example, why Colorado, Nevada, and Arizona are turning purple instead of staying red. "By 2020," Chait writes, "nonwhite voters should rise from a quarter of the 2008 electorate to one third. In 30 years, "nonwhites will outnumber whites."
Which is why "whites," and especially white men, seem so determined this election cycle to make it harder for nonwhites to exercise their right to vote. The news from the front this week is telling. On Wednesday, in Pennsylvania, GOP Governor Tom Corbett raced to sign a bill that requires photo identification of voters. The day before, in Texas, GOP Attorney General Greg Abbott amended the Lone Star State's complaint against the federal government to seek to strike down the pre-clearance section of the Voting Rights Act, which had in turn been used by the Justice Department to block Texas' recent efforts at a stringent new voter-ID law.
In Wisconsin, meanwhile, a state court judge on Monday blocked the state's new voter ID law, ruling that it unconstitutionally created a new (and lower) class of citizen-voter. Even the Human Rights Council of the United Nations has been dragged into the controversy, by the NAACP, to the great consternation of conservative bloggers and conspiracy theorists. It's all happening because lawmakers are dissatisfied with less onerous identification requirements -- like those just enacted in Virginia -- which allow registered voters to produce a wide range of documentation to establish that they are who they say they are.
What really doesn't make sense to me is that Republicans push for tougher rules for people showing up to vote, but they make it easier to vote absentee.  Talk about an opportunity for fraud.  People who take care of their elderly parents could vote their absentee ballots.  Landlords can register their tenants and vote their ballots, if they expect that the people won't vote on their own.  Of course, much like the idea that people will go to multiple precincts and vote, the idea that somebody would risk felony charges to cast 2 or 3 more absentee votes seems pretty unlikely to me.  There are two reasons for Republicans to push this line, suppression of minority votes and the ability to cast doubt on the validity of elections they are more and more likely to lose.  Unless the party changes its direction soon, they will be explaining away their election losses with imaginary vote fraud, and the true believers will think the election was stolen.

13 comments:

  1. If you need to show an ID to buy beer, take out a loan, or sign up to rent a stupid DVD at Blockbuster it sure as hell does not seem unreasonable to show a damn ID when you vote. Assuming there are politics involved only tries to validate the fallacy that there is some mass conspiracy to keep minority voters at home. Here is some advice; Get off your lazy ass and go get an ID card like any normal person with just an ounce of initiative would do. When we stop coddling people maybe, just maybe, people will start realizing that voting is a privilege not worth taking for granted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is also straight up racism. I don't get IDd approximately 99% of the time I buy beer. I can get credit cards without an ID. Any person over the age of 18 who isn't a felon is eligible to vote. Showing up at a polling place is getting off your lazy ass and showing some initiative.

    I've got a suggestion to Republicans. Try to come up with some ideas which a majority of voters will support, so you con't have to suppress the vote to win election. Stop bashing minorities and come up with ideas they'll vote for. In other words, stop being racist morons.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is politics pure and simple. Just depends on what side of the aisle you call home. Pretty easy to see which side your calling base camp! I have heard the racist chant on this subject too. Honestly, one could argue its racist from either side. Democrats are playing to minorities with handouts and entitlements and need their vote so of course they are going to want to keep the status quo. Instead of lifting up minorities and pulling them into the fold its the Democrats holding them back by turning them into second class citizens who need special rules. Frankly, this administration has created such a deep divide in this country that there are no ideas that a majority of voters will support. Its really sad what has happened. A lot of folks try to blame Republicans but those first two years of Obama and his ego marked a turning point for this country. Seems like yesterday he was telling Republicans to head to the back of the bus. Then the Tea Party comes along and changes the face of the House. Now we are at an impasse that no one is willing to cross.

      Delete
    2. I think it is racist to say Democrats are playing to minorities with handouts and entitlements when the vast majority of handouts and entitlements go to white people.

      Delete
    3. Depends on how you want to spin the numbers. Take welfare for example. Compare whites against any other single minority and you are correct. But, if you lump the minorities together then its a 60/40 split going to the minorities.

      Your naive and kidding yourself if you do not think playing to minorities is in the Democrat play book. I think even MSNBC would report that one as true!

      Delete
  3. Also, these people have already registered to vote. Most of the folks without IDs are elderly. They don't drive, they don't need a driver's license. They've filled out the paperwork to qualify to vote. They are eligible. Why put in a new restriction to address an imaginary threat? Oh, that's right, we don't want those folks to vote because they will vote for Democrats.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Next time I need a Passport, board a plane, write a check, need cold medicine, or one thousand other things that require an ID I will present to them a copy of your blog and say it is a travesty I am being required to prove who I am and tell them they are racist for even asking me, LOL! That no ID at the airport seems like an especially good idea (if you’re a terrorist that is, Ha!)

      Delete
    2. I haven't been carded ever when writing a check. I don't have a passport. I have never been carded when buying cold medicine. I did get carded at the bank, but I show my ID very very infrequently. I did get carded when I voted though. Thanks for the comments, I love having Republicans claim they aren't racist.

      Delete
    3. Good for you on the check writing. Pretty sure that's the exception though. Maybe if you are writing them in your neck of the woods. Try taking a 50 mile trip and I'm betting you will be showing that ID. Just stretch those legs a bit. Big world out there.

      You have to find it interesting that in the 2008 Presidential election 96% of black voters supported Obama. Do you believe white Republicans would vote that way? Don’t kid yourself on that one. The whole racist angle is interesting though. Even Holder played the race card when backed in a corner. Time to stop making excuses if you ask me. I guess a Democrat would call that racist? You have to give Republicans a little credit though. The easy way out in this election is to play to minorities to get their vote like Democrats do. Tell them they have been wronged by the other political party and how those wrongs are going to be righted. Republicans have come out and said they are going to reduce handouts, shrink government, etc. Considering how many people are currently suckling on the government (regardless of race) that takes some brass balls. . . . .

      Delete
  4. Actually, Democrats don't have to, because the Republicans are so obvious in their bigotry that minorities are repelled.

    As for playing the victim card, what the hell do the Republicans do? Christians and white people are repressed in this country? Are you kidding me? You have to be ignorant or a hateful racist to believe that. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and go with ignorant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Believe what you want. I guess if you say it enough it must be true. As for me I make up my own mind and do not feel the need to tow the line for any party. Do you believe in global warming, the tea party is racist, Capitalism is evil, increase taxes on the rich, etc.? Of course you do. I can see all of your tags and they are straight out of the Democrat playbook. So I ask you; who is the ignorant one? You just believe whatever your party tells you to believe. You only look at polls and studies that support those beliefs and blindly follow them. My advice to you is to stop drinking the Obama Kool-Aid and realize you are allowed to make up your own mind. I don't mean to come down hard on you but I get so sick of the polarization every time I pick up the paper or turn on the TV. Republicans are guilty too but Obama has done more to drive a stake between the parties than every President before him combined. History will judge this administration and the ones before it but if he is not remembered for being "The Great Divider" I will be really surprised.

      Delete
    2. Yeah, I could say the same thing about Bush, and probably be more accurate. Do you believe that tax cuts boost the economy, that global warming isn't happening, that capitalism has no faults, that Republicans aren't racist, and that you don't tow a party line? I was a conservative Republican, but I decided that Bush and company were fucking morons or assholes or both, and I got the heck out. My playbook is my own. I agree with the Democrats on a lot of issues, and I consider Obama, while flawed, to be two or three times better than Bush. So far as I know, Obama has invaded two fewer countries than Bush, while also finding Bin Laden, who Bush wanted dead or alive, until he didn't. The republican party is a half assed bunch of clowns who think they can turn back the clock to 1950 and make the world a better place. That includes the whites only drinking fountains. If you don't agree with me, fine, I don't really care. Don't worry about whether I tow the party line. I've been voting Democratic just because I am pissed off that the Republican party has so many terrible candidates and ideas. They seem to think Paul Ryan is some math whiz, when he can't do addition and subtraction. Taxes are not too high. They are at 50 year lows, and they are more regressive than they have been that whole time. Republicans need to come out of fantasyland and embrace reality.

      Delete
  5. More on Democrats courting minorities:

    http://www.balloon-juice.com/2012/03/21/entering-white-cecelia/

    ReplyDelete