Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Taxes Are the Foundation of Democracy

David Cay Johnson via Mark Thoma:
The top conclusion I have come to, the one that like our imaginary intergalactic researchers report must come first because it matters most, is that America with all of its greatness, its freedoms, and its potential, is, like democracy itself, the child of tax.
Two centuries of debate and thoughtful consideration by the ancient Greeks gave us the moral basis for progressive taxation and, in turn, the radical ideas that people could govern themselves and that just because a man had money he was not entitled to a larger voice in the body politic.
Seven years under a central government without the power to tax or regulate commerce destroyed the first American republic and created the need for the second, with its strong powers of tax and regulation.
We are abusing our child -- which is to say we are abusing America -- with all of the hate-filled, nonsensical, demagogic talk about tax that dominates one of our political parties and intimidates the other.
We have forgotten the wise words of Edmund Burke, the founder of modern conservatism, who in his 1793 letter made the telling observation that "the revenue of the state is the state."
We seem to think we can raise generations to hate tax, when hate is never a good emotion. We spread tax illiteracy, with no regard for how it undermines America, the liberties of the people, and the very idea of self-governance. If you doubt that, just remember the total disconnect between what the Boston Tea Party was about and what modern Tea Partiers say is their cause.
Tax is not a pleasant subject and never will be. Neither are the responsibilities of child care, like calming bedtime fears about imagined monsters lurking in the shadows. Parents who perform these duties, showing their love by their actions, make for productive adults, while those who shirk the unpleasant realities of parenting often discover what a nightmare a child can grow up to become.
We need to nurture America. We need to do the hard work of changing our tax system to fit the times, of comforting those afflicted by change, and conquering the imaginary monsters perpetuated by politicians consumed by anti-tax ideology and the pursuit of power. We need to remember all six noble purposes in our Constitution's preamble, and we need to take care of our common property, forgetting neither our purposes nor our investments in the commonwealth.
Without taxes there is no America. Taxes are the foundation of the commonwealth, of the goods and services that make society work, and on which private wealth is built. Unless we build a sturdy foundation, we cannot prosper, we cannot remain free. Skyscrapers built on sand will fall.
I just don't understand why so many average Americans seem to put all of the blame for their economic struggles on the government.  While there are problems with our government, they are taking a worse screwing from the private businesses they want to let loose from regulation.  Somehow, the business lobby has been able to sell the rubes a pretty amazing story.  We may need more government, we may need less government, but we definitely need better government, and starving said government of revenues is not going to get us better government.  Republicans too often seem to try to make government dysfunctional, instead of trying to proactively make government better.  Their tax policies are beyond stupid, and their aversion to public investment in infrastructure is crippling.  If they won't work to make government better, they should get the hell out of the way.

3 comments:

  1. Couldn’t agree more! Bigger government is the answer! I know those conservative Tea Partiers will say the government is spending too much but it seems like if we just taxed all of these rich guys until they were broke and redistributed their wealth the government could be bigger and control every aspect of our lives. I mean, I hate it when I go to the grocery and there are 4 kinds of corn flakes. The government should mandate only 1 brand. Four brands is just plain wasteful. If those companies weren’t making all of those varieties we could hire more people for the government. And another thing, I see all of these people driving big SUV’s and gas guzzling trucks. You should have to fill out a government form explaining why you have to have it and then be forced to pay a huge tax even if you do. And why do we have to work until we’re 65. That’s crap. If the government was bigger I could just retire at 40 and live off of the other people who are paying those big taxes. Lastly we really need to step up screwing American businesses and shut them down. Just outsource everything to China. I know, I know, they employ people and stuff but they just take advantage of people most of the time. No real value. If there are no businesses left we can just all sit around and get our government checks. That will be awesome. I really hope my buddy Obama stays and we liberals gain full control of government. We can put our plan into action and no one will stop us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I don't happen to see any mention of corn flakes, outsourcing, SUVs or retirement at 40 anywhere in that post. You must be arguing about something else, or you can't read.

    ReplyDelete